"Passive Resistance" Chapter XVII by MK Gandhi

-

 



Chapter XVII, "Passive Resistance," is arguably the philosophical core of Hind Swaraj, where Mahatma Gandhi presents his revolutionary concept of Satyagraha (Truth-Force).

In this chapter, presented in the form of a dialogue between the "Editor" (Gandhi) and the "Reader," Gandhi argues that passive resistance is the superior and only truly just method for securing rights and achieving Swaraj (self-rule).


Detailed explanation 

1. The Fundamental Distinction: Soul-Force vs. Body-Force


Gandhi establishes the complete moral and spiritual separation between his method and all forms of violence:

 - Body-Force (Brute Force): This is the use of arms, physical violence, or even punitive laws to coerce an opponent into submitting to one's will. Gandhi condemns it because it is contrary to the very spirit of peace and love, and, crucially, because it assumes the resistor is absolutely right and the opponent is absolutely wrong. Since no human can claim absolute truth, using violence (which forces the opponent to suffer for one's judgment) is morally indefensible.

 - Soul-Force (Passive Resistance/Satyagraha): This is "a method of securing rights by personal suffering." It is the refusal to obey an unjust law based on a clear conscience, coupled with the willingness to accept the full penalty (imprisonment, death, etc.) for that disobedience. This act of self-sacrifice involves the internalization of suffering, which is deemed "infinitely superior" to inflicting suffering on others.


2. Passive Resistance as the Weapon of the Strong


Gandhi strongly refutes the idea that passive resistance is merely a pragmatic weapon for the militarily weak. He argues:

 -Courage is the Prerequisite: True courage is not required to fire a gun from behind cover, but rather to "approach a cannon and be blown to pieces with a smiling face." The brute force man is driven by fear of the opponent, whereas the passive resister is driven only by the fear of God (or conscience) and is fearless of all human power.

 - Matchless and Permanent Power: Soul-Force is "matchless" and "superior to the force of arms." It is a weapon that "never rusts and cannot be stolen." Unlike violence, which only yields temporary and corrupt results (since the violent means poisons the end), soul-force creates permanent change through internal growth and moral development.


3. The Key to Swaraj (Self-Rule)

The chapter connects passive resistance directly to the attainment of true Swaraj.

 - Rejection of Unjust Authority: A man who has realized his "manhood" fears only God and is not bound by "man-made laws." Gandhi points out the absurdity that governments do not force obedience but merely state the penalty for disobedience. He urges the Reader to realize that it is "unmanly to obey laws that are unjust," and that the tyranny of the government will cease the moment the people refuse to cooperate and willingly accept the punishment.

 - A Moral and Spiritual Discipline: Gandhi concludes that a true passive resister must uphold the highest moral standards, including perfect chastity, voluntary poverty, adherence to truth, and cultivation of fearlessness. This implies that political action is fundamentally a spiritual endeavor; to overthrow an unjust external government, one must first gain mastery over one's self.


In essence, Chapter XVII shifts the focus of the independence struggle from an external, physical battle against the British to an internal, ethical, and spiritual battle fought through self-purification and self-sacrifice.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Boy Who Broke The Bank by Ruskin Bond

-
Image
The Boy Who Broke The Bank by Ruskin Bond Text of the Story  Nathu grumbled to himself as he swept the steps of the Pipalnagar Bank, owned by Seth Govind Ram. He used the small broom hurriedly and carelessly, and the dust, after rising in a cloud above his head settled down again on the steps.  As Nathu was banging his pan against a dustbin, Sitaram, the washerman’s son, passed by. Sitaram was on his delivery round. He had a bundle of freshly pressed clothes balanced on his head. ‘Don’t raise such dust!’ he called out to Nathu. ‘Are you annoyed because they are still refusing to pay you an extra two rupees a month?’ ‘I don’t wish to talk about it,’ complained the sweeper-boy. ‘I haven’t even received my regular pay.  And this is the twentieth of the month. Who would think a bank would hold up a poor man’s salary? As soon as I get my money, I’m off! Not another week I work in this place.’ And Nathu banged the pan against the dustbin several times, just to emphasize hi...
Read more

"Telephone Conversation" by Wole Soyinka

-
Image
  "Telephone Conversation"                                                                   Wole Soyinka   The price seemed reasonable, location Indifferent. The landlady swore she lived Off premises. Nothing remained But self-confession. "Madam," I warned, "I hate a wasted journey--I am African." Silence. Silenced transmission of Pressurized good-breeding. Voice, when it came, Lipstick coated, long gold-rolled Cigarette-holder pipped. Caught I was foully. "HOW DARK?" . . . I had not misheard . . . "ARE YOU LIGHT OR VERY DARK?" Button B, Button A. *  Stench Of rancid breath of public hide-and-speak. Red booth. Red pillar box. Red double-tiered Omnibus squelching tar. It  was  real! Shamed By ill-mannered silence, surrender Pushed dumbfounded to beg simplification. Considerate she was, varying t...
Read more

Group discussion : types, merits and demerits.

-
 Group discussion is when a group of people comes together to discuss a certain topic that involves  sharing ideas or activities. Group Discussion is a combination of two words 'Group' and 'Discussion.'  Group A group means many people are working together to achieve some targets. The performance of a group depends on the collaborative work of the individuals. The team of three or more than three people is considered as a group. Discussion Discussion means exchanging ideas between two or more than two people, which is generally a face-to-face interaction. It is a process of talking between people to reach a specific decision. It is also defined as a conversation about a specific topic. The result or end product of group discussion can be a particular decision, enhanced knowledge, actions, an argument, doubt-clearing, disagreement, etc. Types of Group discussions are:  Factual Group Discussions Opinion-Based Group Discussion Group conversations based on case studies A...
Read more